|
It was for nearly two months in the spring of 1933 that Charles Thomas Babcoke was simply gone.
The 52-year-old farmer lived south of Eldon in rural Miller County, not far from the countryside surrounding what is today known as Stark Caverns. Neighbors knew him as a farmer and churchman, a man whose habits were so predictable that his sudden absence attracted attention. There were explanations for where he had gone. Babcoke had left Missouri to become a traveling salesman, people were told. Perhaps he had gone to Kansas or possibly Oklahoma. He had supposedly turned his farm over to another man before leaving. But there was a problem … Charles Babcoke had never left his farm. On May 23, 1933, searchers discovered his decomposing body concealed in a shallow grave behind one of his farm buildings. He had been shot. What followed was one of the strangest murder investigations and most protracted criminal prosecutions in Miller County history, a case involving missing livestock, a dead man's watch, and an abandoned farmhouse whose clock inexplicably continued to run. Then came sensational newspaper reports of a possible "murder farm," two deadlocked juries, two convictions and two trips through Missouri's appellate courts. At the center of it all was Babcoke's neighbor, George C. Thompson, who consistently maintained he was innocent. Charles Babcoke had deep roots in Miller County. County records show that he married Eliza A. Crum at Eldon on February 26, 1911. His parents were Joseph Newton Babcoke and Martha Bliss, members of a family that had been established in Miller County for generations. By 1933, Charles was farming south of Eldon while Eliza was spending time in Kansas City, where contemporary reports said she was employed as a domestic worker. That left Charles largely alone on the farm. In hindsight, testimony about his behavior during his final days seemed to border on ominous. Roy Thacker, a young farmhand, later testified that he spent the night of March 22 at Babcoke's place. According to coverage of Thompson's September 1933 trial, Babcoke had become unusually cautious after dark. On one occasion he extinguished a light while the two men were talking. Thacker said Babcoke warned him not to unlock the door unless he knew who was outside. More troubling was something Babcoke said on what may have been his final night alive. He had, Thacker recalled, "something to tell him." But Babcoke hesitated. He was afraid Thacker would laugh. Whatever Charles Babcoke wanted to say, he apparently never said it and Thacker testified that he last saw him March 23. Babcoke's Missouri death certificate would eventually give his date of death only approximately—"About Mar 23 1933"—and list the cause as a gunshot wound and the manner of death as murder. But in March, there was no body and no known murder. There was only a missing farmer. George C. Thompson lived nearby and knew Babcoke well. When questions arose about Charles's whereabouts, Thompson had an explanation. In later accounts he said Babcoke had decided to leave farming temporarily and try his hand at salesmanship. Exactly where Babcoke had supposedly gone seemed to vary. At Thompson's first trial, witnesses testified that they had heard several versions. One recalled Thompson saying Babcoke had gone to Kansas City. Another said Thompson placed him in Oklahoma or Kansas, learning to sell automobiles. Other testimony concerned an arrangement under which Thompson claimed Babcoke had turned over the farm, livestock and equipment to him. Years later, Miller County Sheriff Lafe King recalled the investigation in an article published in True Detective Mysteries. According to King, Thompson offered a simple explanation whenever questions arose about the missing farmer: “Charlie had gone away.” Thompson maintained that Babcoke had voluntarily left the area and entrusted his farm and property to him, an explanation that became increasingly difficult to accept as the investigation unfolded. As the weeks passed, however, Thompson was doing more than watching a neighbor's farm; he was using Babcoke's property. Livestock changed hands and farm equipment was being used. Personal possessions belonging to the missing man appeared in Thompson's possession. Even Babcoke's watch was involved. Contemporary newspaper accounts said investigators found Thompson carrying Babcoke's pocket watch and possessing clothing and other property belonging to him. Thompson had an explanation for that, too. When he eventually testified in his own defense, he said Babcoke had entrusted the watch and other personal effects to him before leaving. "No, I did not," Thompson answered when asked at trial whether he had killed Charles Babcoke. His position remained consistent in one important respect for the rest of his life: George Thompson denied being a murderer. Yet one of the strangest details of the case concerned an ordinary household clock. When relatives entered Babcoke's abandoned farmhouse after his disappearance, there were few indications that its owner had deliberately embarked upon an extended journey. His gun remained there while food or evidence of a meal had been left behind. And an old eight-day clock was still running. The detail became so closely associated with the murder that a later national crime magazine titled its account of the case "The Clue of the Running Clock." The magazine embellished portions of the story in the dramatic fashion common to the genre, but the clock itself was not simply a writer's invention. At Thompson's trial, Babcoke's brother-in-law Henry Uptergrove testified that when relatives were at the house on May 16, the clock was "still running." Someone apparently had been inside the supposedly abandoned farmhouse. Roy Thacker, a 24-year-old farmhand who occasionally stayed with Babcoke and may have been among the last people to see him alive, possessed a key to the farmhouse. Thacker acknowledged entering the house after Babcoke disappeared. He noticed that Babcoke's Sunday clothes were gone and initially assumed the farmer had gone to Eldon. But Thacker had also witnessed Babcoke's uneasiness shortly before he vanished, such as his nervousness after dark, his reluctance to open the door to strangers, and his cryptic admission that he had "something to tell" Thacker but never did. Other testimony, however, indicated clothing disappeared from the house and later reappeared. Money and livestock soon became central to the investigation. Babcoke reportedly owned 17 head of cattle before his disappearance and Thompson, meanwhile, was in financial difficulty. E. T. Collins of the Bank of Eldon testified during the first trial that Thompson executed a mortgage involving cattle on April 18. When the bank later took nine animals to satisfy the debt, Collins testified that only one of the nine actually belonged to Thompson. Babcoke's wife also became suspicious. Eliza returned from Kansas City and pursued legal action over cattle she believed belonged to her husband. A contemporary Kansas City newspaper reported that she had gone back to Miller County specifically to investigate livestock that had disappeared from the farm. Thompson maintained that his possession of Babcoke's livestock and property resulted from an arrangement between the two men. But there was still no Charles Babcoke to confirm Thompson's story. Then came May 23, 1933. Searchers gathered at the Babcoke property. Near one of the farm buildings, something looked wrong. Later accounts variously called the structure a barn, milk shed or wagon shed, but investigators noticed disturbed ground and farm implements that appeared to have been moved and that inspired them to begin digging. Only a short depth beneath the soil, they encountered human remains. Charles Babcoke had been home on his farm all along. His badly decomposed body had been concealed in a shallow grave. One contemporary account said barely six inches of dirt covered it. Miller County's official death-record index lists Charles T. Babcoke's death as March 23, 1933. The surviving coroner-inquest index records an inquest dated May 25 and lists the cause simply as "Gunshot Wound." The death certificate was more explicit about what authorities believed had occurred. Babcoke had been murdered. The precise firearm involved became less certain as the story was retold. Some newspaper reports described a rifle; others mentioned a shotgun. At Thompson's first trial, Miller County Coroner Dr. J. R. Ellison reportedly testified that the fatal wound was just below the skull and could have been caused by a .45-caliber revolver or a .410 firing a slug. A 1937 retrospective instead claimed Babcoke had been shot with a .22 rifle. Regardless, the conclusion was that Charles Babcoke died from a gunshot wound. On May 24, 1933, the Kansas City Journal printed an extraordinary phrase: "MURDER FARM MAY BE BARED BY DISCOVERY." For a brief period, authorities and reporters wondered whether Babcoke's death might be only one part of something much larger. Several people connected with the family or neighborhood had died or disappeared during previous years. Babcoke's half-brother George was missing. Jim Butler, stepfather of Frank and Oliver Richardson, had also disappeared. Even the earlier death of Babcoke's father attracted renewed attention. Searchers reportedly dug around both the Babcoke and Thompson properties looking for additional bodies. There was even a bizarre story about the skeleton of a missing man's dog being discovered chained to a tree. The facts eventually proved to be considerably less sensational. George Babcoke was found alive, working near Butterfield, Missouri. Butler was located in Kansas City. Another man authorities had sought returned. There was no proven "murder farm." There was, however, one murdered farmer and investigators increasingly focused upon George Thompson. Thompson was charged with first-degree murder. The case drew enormous attention. Miller County reporting of the period estimated that approximately 2,000 people descended upon Tuscumbia for the opening of his September 1933 trial. The prosecution did have a significant problem: no eyewitness could place a gun in Thompson's hand at the moment Babcoke died and there was no confession. The case was circumstantial, yet prosecutors worked to build their case piece by piece. Babcoke had disappeared, Thompson took control of his farm and Babcoke's livestock and property passed into Thompson's possession. Witnesses recalled differing explanations from Thompson about where Babcoke had gone while a supposed agreement governing the property could not be produced when witnesses asked about it. Then there was Babcoke's watch and other belongings associated with Thompson. Finally, Babcoke himself was found buried on the farm Thompson was operating. Thompson took the witness stand and offered an innocent explanation. Babcoke, he said, intended to leave and become a salesman. He had asked Thompson to operate the farm and safeguard some of his possessions. Thompson told the jury he had no idea anything had happened to Babcoke until the body was found. The jury listened and most of them believed the state had failed to prove its case. After four ballots, the jury stood with nine for acquittal, three for conviction and the judge declared a mistrial. The state tried Thompson again in January 1934. The jury could not agree and it resulted in another mistrial. Thompson had now faced two juries for Charles Babcoke's murder and neither could convict him. The state tried a third time in March 1934. This time prosecutors obtained a conviction and Thompson received a life sentence. But the case still wasn't finished since Thompson appealed. The Missouri Supreme Court ordered another trial after a dispute involving Thompson's effort to obtain a change of venue and allegations of prejudice against the trial judge. For the fourth trial, another judge, W. M. Dinwiddie, presided. In October 1934, approximately a year and a half after Charles Babcoke disappeared, George C. Thompson faced yet another jury. This one convicted him of first-degree murder and again, the punishment was life imprisonment. On November 2, 1934, Thompson entered the Missouri State Penitentiary at Jefferson City. Thompson continued fighting the conviction. In March 1936, the Missouri Supreme Court finally allowed the life sentence to stand. The Iberia Sentinel, looking back over the extraordinary prosecution, described the state's case as a “weave of circumstantial evidence.” It also noted that Thompson "maintained throughout all of his trials that he was innocent of the crime." Four trials had been required and two juries had failed to convict him. One conviction had been overturned and the final conviction survived. In the eyes of Missouri law, the question was settled. George Thompson was the murderer of Charles Babcoke. Thompson did not serve a long life sentence. On November 16, 1937, he died inside the Missouri State Penitentiary in Jefferson City. The Iberia Sentinel announced: “MILLER CO. SLAYER DIES IN STATE PRISON AT 76.” National detective magazines turned the Babcoke case into true-crime entertainment. One emphasized Sheriff Lafe King's investigation. Another built its story around the mysterious household clock that continued ticking while its owner lay buried outside. But beneath the sensationalism remained a remarkably human story. Charles Babcoke had apparently sensed that something was wrong shortly before his death. He had become cautious after dark and affirmed there was something he wanted to tell Roy Thacker. Then he vanished. For weeks, explanations substituted for answers. He was in Kansas. He was in Oklahoma. He had become a salesman. He had turned his farm over to someone else. Meanwhile, his livestock changed hands, his possessions appeared elsewhere and inside the empty farmhouse, the clock kept running. Then came the digging. The discovery of Charles Babcoke beneath the soil of his own farm transformed a local disappearance into one of Miller County's most disturbing murder cases. Four trials, two hung juries, two convictions and repeated appellate proceedings eventually determined George Thompson's fate. Through it all, Thompson never supplied the one thing that might have answered every lingering question: a confession. He died behind the walls of the Missouri State Penitentiary in 1937, still maintaining his innocence. By then, the courts had spoken. George Thompson had been convicted of murdering Charles Babcoke and sentenced to spend the remainder of his life in prison. The verdict, however, could not fill every blank left behind on that Miller County farm. No witness had seen the fatal shot fired nor was there a confession to explain what happened. Even some contemporary accounts disagreed over some of the most basic details of the killing. What remained certain was considerably simpler. In the spring of 1933, Charles Babcoke disappeared from his farm. Someone attempted to make that disappearance look permanent, burying him beneath a few inches of Missouri soil and allowing the world to believe he had simply gone away. He had not gone anywhere. He had been home all along. Jeremy P. Ämick is author of the historical compilations “Moments on the Moreau,” “Beyond the Moreau,” and “Voices of the Moreau.”
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorJeremy P. Ämick is an award-winning author and historian dedicated to preserving music, military and local histories. Archives
November 2026
Categories |
RSS Feed